BooksReviews

Why A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder Is a Must‑Read Thriller: Student Review

‘A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder’ is an extremely intriguing and alluring novel, a perfect mix of thriller elements, plot twists that make you jump in your seat, and suspense that makes you want to skip to the end. When I first heard about this book in school, everyone who had read it was bursting with excitement, waiting to tell anyone who’d listen what they thought of the ending.

A flat lay of the book 'A Good Girl's Guide to Murder' by Holly Jackson, featuring a white cover with bold black lettering, surrounded by green plants and red string.
Photo source: missknown

Why I Picked Up This Book

My decision to pick up this book at an airport Crossword bookstore at 6 in the morning, running on barely any sleep, might have been the best decision I have made in a while.

I decided to pick up a book to read during the long wait for our flight, saw this book, and wondered why not? It had been on my to-read list anyway, but it was a hard choice since I had wanted another book for a long time too, and I ended up calling a friend to ask which one to buy. I definitely do not regret my decision.

Image of a mystery-themed bulletin board with notes, photographs, and strings connecting various elements, accompanied by information about the book 'A Good Girl's Guide to Murder' by Holly Jackson.
When Andie goes missing on a mundane, normal day, as everyone follows their routines in a small town, chaos is unleashed. Source: Internet

A Quick Look at the Premise

The story starts five years from the present, in a little town called ‘Little Kilton’, with a sweet and innocent high school girl, Andie and her kind, caring and thoughtful boyfriend, Sal Singh, but masks are up everywhere; is anyone ever truly who they seem to be?

When Andie goes missing on a mundane, normal day, as everyone follows their routines in a small town, chaos is unleashed.

When her blood is found in Sal’s car, and his whereabouts during the suspected timeframe she went missing are seemingly unknown, all the attention turns on a boy who was admired by the rest of the town up until that moment. The day the cops call him in for questioning is the same day he is found in the forest, overdosed on sleeping pills, after a confession text was sent from his phone to his father.

One thing about this case is that up until now, Andie’s body hadn’t been found.

Promotional image for 'A Good Girl's Guide to Murder,' featuring two characters closely examining a smartphone, with a wooden background.
She interviews Sal’s brother first, Ravi Singh, who calls himself ‘ravishing’. “I’m ravishing, get it? Ravi – shing. Ravi Singh.” Source: Internet

The Characters Who Pulled Me In

Pippa Fitz Amobi, an aspiring student who, before his death, saw Sal as an inspirational figure, isn’t sure about the verdict passed down by the townsfolk and, at the same time, has an Extended Project Qualification that needs a topic.

So, she has a project, an astoundingly sharp mind, and an unsolved case that has gone on for years. Whatever will happen next?

She interviews Sal’s brother first, Ravi Singh, who calls himself ‘ravishing’. “I’m ravishing, get it? Ravi – shing. Ravi Singh.”  – Ravi Singh, a popular dialogue amongst fans of this book series, before teaming up with him as he helps work on clearing his brother and family’s name.

He too desperately wants to find out what happened to his brother and his brother’s girlfriend, Andie, get some closure, and finally make the whole of Little Kilton stop treating the Singh family like social pariahs because of what they suspected happened that night, because he too believes with all his heart that his gentle, doting brother couldn’t possibly have done this to someone he so obviously cared about.

A poster for 'A Good Girl's Guide to Murder' featuring details about the film including running time, director, producer, and cast names. The background includes an identification file and photographs.
Source: Internet

What Makes This Book So Gripping

When Pippa receives the police interview records, she finds many gaps in the police investigation. Almost like the police accepted what they wanted to hear, and what they wanted to hear was ‘Sal is guilty’.

Pippa and Ravi map out the timelines of when Sal’s friends said he left, and when his father said he arrived home, moving faster than would have been possible, as they trace the shortest possible route that could have happened that night while trying to fit them together. They find that even while taking the least amount of time possible, there is no way that Sal could have killed Andie, disposed of the body and made it home in time at what the witness has stated.

Filled with giddy joy at the fact that Sal was most likely innocent, Ravi suggests going to the police with this information, but Pippa insists that they first find out who actually killed Andie, if she is even truly dead.

Plot twists, screenshotted Instagram pictures, drug dealers, more uncovered crimes of roofies at parties, blackmail, shocking uncovered truths, missing dogs (I will never forgive you for this, Holly Jackson, and we will always love and cherish you, Barney) and a couple of hundred pages that had me quivering in excitement, we reach a point where Pippa is finally close to getting her A* on her EPQ.  

Truths about some people are revealed, and not everyone is who Pippa, and the rest of Little Kilton, thought they were.

When someone realises Pippa is getting too close, she starts receiving threats in school, and at home, she is told to leave the case alone by whoever is threatening her. However, Pippa realises that whoever is responsible for these atrocious crimes to both high schoolers is still in town, and someone very close to her.

In a dramatic twist, it is revealed that Sal’s friends were blackmailed into taking away his alibi for that dreadful night that led to both their deaths.

Pip suspects someone she has known her entire life, someone who was close with Sal, and Andie too; someone she believes is the killer.

The Reading Experience: My Reactions & Reflections

Okay, I literally had to close the book, gather my bearings for 20 minutes, and then board my flight. I read so much in a couple of hours because the book was so good.

After shocking twists, revealed truths, and a story which pulled many gasps from deep within me, comes a part which has me squealing and bouncing around in shock and excitement as, moments later, Pippa is attacked, when the hero of the day, Ravi, shows up with Pippa’s father and saves her in the nick of time.

Every single little piece adds up so perfectly in this intricately constructed web of crime, so gorgeously woven by the author.

It is enlightening when you reach the ending and finally put together the parts that didn’t make sense, or even the ones you thought fit perfectly, but truly had to be taken apart and built completely differently.

Promotional poster for 'A Good Girl's Guide to Murder' featuring a girl in a green and white patterned shirt, with a colorful mural of an angel and rainbow in the background.
This book combines themes of thriller, mystery, and suspense, with a little bit of humour and fun injected into it. Photo credit: Internet

Themes That Stand Out

This book combines themes of thriller, mystery, and suspense, with a little bit of humour and fun injected into it, while showing the bond between Pippa’s family and friends, showing how even victims aren’t always the perfect angels painted cleanly by communities, and how even the most seemingly normal people are capable of committing such crimes.

Andie may have been cruel, a bully and many more things, but she did not deserve to be killed and hidden, a fate that nobody deserves.  

Sal’s case was even more saddening, and it made me realise how many cases like this there are, where truly innocent people were blamed and undeserving of what happened to them. His family were cast aside and blamed for the loss of their “beautiful, young and bright Andie” while they should have been comforted and shown sympathy, as they too were grieving the loss of their child and brother.

Cover of the book 'A Good Girl's Guide to Murder' by Holly Jackson featuring red string and push pins over a grid background.
Source: ripplefoundation

Final Verdict & Recommendation

I couldn’t concentrate on anything after I read all 432 pages in one sitting, and it probably ruined the trip because, when I think of it now, all I remember is how dumbfounded I was after finishing that book.

What delighted me even more about that book was that it is a trilogy, and that the other books are even more thrilling and suspenseful.

While many have watched the Netflix show and deemed it overrated, keep in mind the saying ‘Never judge a book by its TV adaptation.’

I would, and have, recommend it to anyone who asks me for books, especially crime readers. Even people who haven’t bothered to read Harry Potter managed to finish this book and squeal in excitement from the suspense.

I’d give this book a 10 out of 10.

Advika Karve

Grade 9, JBCN International School, Mumbai

About our Writing Program Student

Advika is a 13-year-old who loves breakdancing, art, and listening to music. She also enjoys spending time with animals and playing the guitar.

Would you like your child/ student to research and write with clarity and confidence? Support their growth with The Write Compass. Admissions are now open for the I.N.S.P.I.R.E Online Writing Program (Grade 8+). Fill out the registration form to begin their journey.

The Lifestyle Portal

Writing Mentor, Writer, Artist, Human.

Leave a Reply